Real Madrid have once again asserted their dominance over city rivals Atletico Madrid, securing a dramatic 4-2 penalty shootout victory in the Champions League Round of 16 after a tense 2-2 aggregate stalemate. However, the narrative of this clash will be forever etched with the controversy surrounding a disallowed Julian Alvarez penalty, a moment of sheer bewilderment that ultimately shifted the game’s momentum.
The Riyadh Air Metropolitano witnessed a pulsating encounter, sparked into life within 27 seconds by Conor Gallagher’s lightning-fast strike, leveling the tie after Real’s first-leg advantage. Atletico, buoyed by their early lead, adopted a disciplined defensive approach, frustrating Real’s star-studded attack for the majority of the match. While Atletico’s resilience was commendable, the spotlight inevitably fell on the dramatic penalty shootout, specifically, the Julian Alvarez penalty against Real Madrid.
The Defining Moment: Julian Alvarez Penalty Against Real Madrid
After successful conversions from both sides, Alvarez stepped up, aiming to level the shootout at 2-2. What transpired was a moment of pure footballing theatre. As Alvarez struck the ball, he slipped, resulting in a Julian Alvarez double touch. The ball found the net, initially prompting celebrations from the Atletico faithful. However, VAR intervened, and referee Szymon Marciniak disallowed the goal, citing the infringement.
The confusion that ensued was palpable. The scoreboard initially displayed 2-2, adding to the bewilderment. The crucial moment, the Julian Alvarez double touch was replayed, revealing the Argentine’s unfortunate slip and the subsequent double contact with the ball. This incident, the Julian Alvarez penalty, became the defining moment of the night.
View this post on Instagram
The Julian Alvarez Double Touch Explained
The laws of the game, specifically Article 14.1 of the IFAB regulations, are unambiguous: “The kicker must not play the ball again until it has touched another player.” This rule, designed to prevent double touches and rebounds, applied directly to Alvarez’s situation. The referee’s decision, after VAR review, was technically correct. Similar instances, such as Riyad Mahrez’s disallowed penalty for Leicester City against Manchester City in 2017 and Aleksandar Mitrovic’s mishap for Fulham against Newcastle in 2023, underscore the strict adherence to this rule.
The fallout from the Julian Alvarez penalty was immediate and far-reaching. Atletico coach Diego Simeone expressed his skepticism, questioning the VAR’s intervention and the visibility of the second touch. “I’ve never seen a penalty where they’ve called the VAR, but well, they would have seen that he touched it. I want to believe they saw he touched it,” he said. His frustration was evident, reflecting the sudden shift in the game’s narrative.
Real Madrid’s Carlo Ancelotti, on the other hand, acknowledged the correct decision. “They detected it. When we realized there was this doubt, they had already detected it on VAR,” he stated, confirming the clarity of the infringement. Real goalkeeper Thibaut Courtois echoed this sentiment, admitting the unfortunate nature of the incident but emphasizing the rule’s clarity.
Game Momentum Shifted: Real Madrid vs Atletico Madrid
Game Momentum Shifted: Real Madrid vs Atletico MadridThe psychological impact of the disallowed Julian Alvarez penalty was undeniable. Real Madrid, seizing the opportunity, capitalized on Atletico’s misfortune. Fede Valverde converted his penalty, establishing a 3-1 lead. Although Jan Oblak briefly rekindled Atletico’s hopes with a save, Marcos Llorente’s missed penalty and Antonio Rudiger’s decisive strike sealed Real’s victory.
The incident, while bizarre, highlights the rigorous application of football’s laws, even in high-stakes matches. The Julian Alvarez penalty against Real Madrid will be remembered as a moment where technicality and misfortune intertwined, ultimately influencing the outcome of a crucial Champions League tie.
The win extends Real Madrid’s impressive record against Atletico in penalty shootouts, marking their sixth consecutive victory in such encounters. It also marks the fifth time Atletico have been eliminated from the Champions League knockout stages by their city rivals. Real Madrid now progresses to the quarter-finals, and their pursuit of a 16th European Cup title continues.
While Real Madrid celebrate their victory, the shadow of the Julian Alvarez penalty will linger, a poignant reminder of how a fleeting moment of misfortune can alter the course of a footballing contest.
